Captains with a Traitor
For 6–8 players, with at least three on each team. On each team, one Gunner may secretly play for the other team.
- The Traitor wins with their real team, that is, when the Captain of the team they sit in is eliminated. Traitors do not know one another.
- Every Gunner has a face-down "Oath" beneath their role. The Traitor's Oath is false, and the "Backstab" knife is hidden beneath it. From the outside, everyone shows the same single card.
- A Traitor who attacks an apparent ally is revealed and from then on plays openly for the real team. An honest Gunner of the former team immediately shoots back. That shot takes 1 life point and cannot be cancelled.
- For a revealed Traitor, the real team counts as allies for assistance, shielding, rewards and penalties. Whoever from the former team eliminates them draws 3 cards.
- The 50% Chance of Traitors setting is on by default. With it, either both teams have a Traitor or neither does; without it, Traitors are always present.
- Choosing an apparent ally as the target of any shot or "Duel" reveals the Traitor, whatever they use: a card, a character ability, Gold Rush equipment ("Bottle", "Pardner") or the Undertaker's "Stray Bullet". The "Epitaph" deal reveals a role to everyone, so it reveals the Traitor too.
- Attacks that hit everyone ("Gatling", "Indians!", "Dynamite") do not reveal the Traitor. An honest Gunner shooting an ally reveals nothing either. If you eliminate a hidden Traitor on your team, you draw 3 cards; if you were wrong and eliminated an honest ally, you discard all your cards.
- While hidden, the Traitor sees the chat of the team they sit in and receives its help. Once revealed, they move to the real team.